LETTER: Brooklin should accept the gift of a church
March 17, 2026
To the Editor:
Should the Town of Brooklin accept the donation of the First Baptist Church? Yes, absolutely. The church and the associated property are centrally located and are very much a part of the heart of Brooklin. Community-owned property—governed by the community and not an individual (the probable outcome if Brooklin votes no)—has proven worldwide to be a worthwhile investment that increases scenic beauty, community spirit and historic preservation. Central Park in New York City is a grand example, but the city-owned Harbor Walk in Belfast is a valuable community asset on a smaller scale.
Brooklin should invest in itself. The property has value as a long-term asset. It would provide space for the community, including parking. Proximity to the Friend Memorial Library would be mutually advantageous, creating a cultural hub in the center of town and drawing patrons to local businesses. Leasing space could support businesses that can’t afford investment costs of real estate but can manage rental expenses.
What are the community costs? There will be ongoing maintenance costs, but it does come with a $100,000 maintenance fund. Future costs can be subsidized and amortized if set up properly. While the property has to be owned by a nonprofit entity, for-profit companies could occupy space and generate revenue to support maintenance needs. Rent could be structured such that a business could invest in infrastructure improvements as an alternative to higher monthly rent. Other variations are possible. Imagine multiple tenants occupying the property, as with the Odd Fellows Hall, which supports three businesses. Likewise, the former high school holds six businesses. See what was done with the old Mountain Ash Inn, which was repurposed into new businesses, community property and private property.
If the town rejects the offer, the property may end up in the hands of an unknown company that could tear it down and develop it without any input from the town. The loss of one of the oldest structures in town would be a shame. Accept the gift, get talented local volunteers to develop a strategy and help keep Brooklin the vibrant and relevant community it is.
Steve and Jen White
Brooklin
The Rising Tide welcomes letters and opinion pieces from a wide variety of viewpoints. Published pieces do not reflect the editorial stance of The Rising Tide or its board, and are not endorsements. To submit a piece to us, email info@risingtide.media. We ask that all submissions be original and exclusive to The Rising Tide.
